BR-O-11: Category O mixed with other breakdowns

An invoice with a VAT breakdown in category O (not subject to VAT) must not contain any other VAT breakdown: such an invoice is entirely outside the scope of VAT. Below: the message, the cause and the fix, and an invoice our validator checked, failing and fixed.

The message validators print

BR-O-11 is a rule of the EN 16931 business rules (CEN validation artefacts 1.3.16) for UBL and CII. It is an error (fatal): a validator rejects the invoice.

UBL and CII
[BR-O-11]-An Invoice that contains a VAT breakdown group (BG-23) with a VAT category code (BT-118) "Not subject to VAT" shall not contain other VAT breakdown groups (BG-23).

What it checks

An invoice with a VAT breakdown in category O (not subject to VAT) must not contain any other VAT breakdown: such an invoice is entirely outside the scope of VAT.

Why invoices fail it

A non-taxable item (a fee passed on at cost) is invoiced on the same invoice as taxable supplies.

How to fix it

Put the non-taxable amount on its own invoice, or treat it as a disbursement outside the invoice, or invoice it under its real category.

A failing invoice and its fix, checked

We start from our sample invoice (two lines at 19 %, Berlin to Stuttgart), written by our own generator as EN 16931 in UBL. The change below (- the failing version, + the fixed one) makes the rule fail. Both versions went through our validator on 2026-11-17 (the XML schema and the official rule files, as POST /einvoice/validate runs them): the fixed one is valid, the failing one reports BR-O-11 and 2 other rules, as a real file with this mistake would.

RuleSeverityWhereMessage
BR-O-11error/ubl:InvoiceAn Invoice that contains a VAT breakdown group (BG-23) with a VAT category code (BT-118) "Not subject to VAT" shall not contain other VAT breakdown groups (BG-23).
BR-S-01error/ubl:InvoiceAn Invoice that contains an Invoice line (BG-25), a Document level allowance (BG-20) or a Document level charge (BG-21) where the VAT category code (BT-151, BT-95 or BT-102) is "Standard rated" shall contain in the VAT breakdown (BG-23) at least one VAT category code (BT-118) equal with "Standard rated".
BR-S-08error/ubl:Invoice/cac:TaxTotal/cac:TaxSubtotal[2]/cac:TaxCategoryFor each different value of VAT category rate (BT-119) where the VAT category code (BT-118) is "Standard rated", the VAT category taxable amount (BT-116) in a VAT breakdown (BG-23) shall equal the sum of Invoice line net amounts (BT-131) plus the sum of document level charge amounts (BT-99) minus the sum of document level allowance amounts (BT-92) where the VAT category code (BT-151, BT-102, BT-95) is "Standard rated" and the VAT rate (BT-152, BT-103, BT-96) equals the VAT category rate (BT-119).
UBL: failing (-) → fixed (+)
  …
        </cac:TaxCategory>
      </cac:TaxSubtotal>
-     <cac:TaxSubtotal>
-       <cbc:TaxableAmount currencyID="EUR">0.00</cbc:TaxableAmount>
-       <cbc:TaxAmount currencyID="EUR">0.00</cbc:TaxAmount>
-       <cac:TaxCategory>
-         <cbc:ID>S</cbc:ID>
-         <cbc:Percent>19.00</cbc:Percent>
-         <cac:TaxScheme>
-           <cbc:ID>VAT</cbc:ID>
-         </cac:TaxScheme>
-       </cac:TaxCategory>
-     </cac:TaxSubtotal>
    </cac:TaxTotal>
    <cac:LegalMonetaryTotal>
  …

The rule as published

Where the rule applies (context) and what must hold (test), unmodified from CEN EN 16931 validation artefacts 1.3.16. An assert fails when its test is false.

Text and test: © CEN/TC 434, EN 16931 validation artefacts, EUPL 1.2. Quoted unmodified; the explanations on this page are Veriport’s.

UBL · CEN EN 16931 validation artefacts (UBL) 1.3.16 · assert · error
context: /ubl:Invoice | /cn:CreditNote
test:    (exists(cac:TaxTotal/cac:TaxSubtotal/cac:TaxCategory[cac:TaxScheme/normalize-space(upper-case(cbc:ID))='VAT']/cbc:ID[normalize-space(.) = 'O']) and count(cac:TaxTotal/cac:TaxSubtotal/cac:TaxCategory[normalize-space(cbc:ID) != 'O'][cac:TaxScheme/normalize-space(upper-case(cbc:ID))='VAT']) = 0) or not(cac:TaxTotal/cac:TaxSubtotal/cac:TaxCategory[cac:TaxScheme/normalize-space(upper-case(cbc:ID))='VAT']/cbc:ID[normalize-space(.) = 'O'])
CII · CEN EN 16931 validation artefacts (CII) 1.3.16 · assert · error
context: //rsm:SupplyChainTradeTransaction/ram:ApplicableHeaderTradeSettlement/ram:ApplicableTradeTax[ram:CategoryCode = 'O'][upper-case(ram:TypeCode) = 'VAT']
test:    not(//ram:ApplicableTradeTax[ram:CategoryCode != 'O'])

Check your own invoice

Drop your XRechnung, ZUGFeRD or Peppol file into a free validator (Peppol BIS, XRechnung, Factur-X): each runs the same rule files and links every finding to its rule page. From your own code, POST /einvoice/validate (reference) returns the same check as JSON, each finding with an explanation field pointing here (5 calls a check, anonymous within the daily allowance).

The whole failing invoice (UBL)
BR-O-11-failing.xml
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<ubl:Invoice xmlns:ubl="urn:oasis:names:specification:ubl:schema:xsd:Invoice-2" xmlns:cac="urn:oasis:names:specification:ubl:schema:xsd:CommonAggregateComponents-2" xmlns:cbc="urn:oasis:names:specification:ubl:schema:xsd:CommonBasicComponents-2">
  <cbc:CustomizationID>urn:cen.eu:en16931:2017</cbc:CustomizationID>
  <cbc:ProfileID>urn:fdc:peppol.eu:2017:poacc:billing:01:1.0</cbc:ProfileID>
  <cbc:ID>2026-017</cbc:ID>
  <cbc:IssueDate>2026-10-20</cbc:IssueDate>
  <cbc:DueDate>2026-11-03</cbc:DueDate>
  <cbc:InvoiceTypeCode>380</cbc:InvoiceTypeCode>
  <cbc:DocumentCurrencyCode>EUR</cbc:DocumentCurrencyCode>
  <cbc:BuyerReference>EK-2026-0345</cbc:BuyerReference>
  <cac:AccountingSupplierParty>
    <cac:Party>
      <cbc:EndpointID schemeID="EM">rechnung@hartmann-webdesign.example</cbc:EndpointID>
      <cac:PostalAddress>
        <cbc:StreetName>Lindenstraße 14</cbc:StreetName>
        <cbc:CityName>Berlin</cbc:CityName>
        <cbc:PostalZone>10969</cbc:PostalZone>
        <cac:Country>
          <cbc:IdentificationCode>DE</cbc:IdentificationCode>
        </cac:Country>
      </cac:PostalAddress>
      <cac:PartyLegalEntity>
        <cbc:RegistrationName>Lena Hartmann — Webdesign</cbc:RegistrationName>
        <cbc:CompanyID>HRB 123456 B</cbc:CompanyID>
      </cac:PartyLegalEntity>
      <cac:Contact>
        <cbc:Name>Lena Hartmann</cbc:Name>
        <cbc:Telephone>+49 30 1234567</cbc:Telephone>
        <cbc:ElectronicMail>rechnung@hartmann-webdesign.example</cbc:ElectronicMail>
      </cac:Contact>
    </cac:Party>
  </cac:AccountingSupplierParty>
  <cac:AccountingCustomerParty>
    <cac:Party>
      <cbc:EndpointID schemeID="EM">buchhaltung@mustermann.example</cbc:EndpointID>
      <cac:PostalAddress>
        <cbc:StreetName>Industrieweg 7</cbc:StreetName>
        <cbc:CityName>Stuttgart</cbc:CityName>
        <cbc:PostalZone>70565</cbc:PostalZone>
        <cac:Country>
          <cbc:IdentificationCode>DE</cbc:IdentificationCode>
        </cac:Country>
      </cac:PostalAddress>
      <cac:PartyLegalEntity>
        <cbc:RegistrationName>Mustermann Maschinenbau GmbH</cbc:RegistrationName>
      </cac:PartyLegalEntity>
      <cac:Contact>
        <cbc:ElectronicMail>buchhaltung@mustermann.example</cbc:ElectronicMail>
      </cac:Contact>
    </cac:Party>
  </cac:AccountingCustomerParty>
  <cac:Delivery>
    <cbc:ActualDeliveryDate>2026-10-15</cbc:ActualDeliveryDate>
  </cac:Delivery>
  <cac:PaymentMeans>
    <cbc:PaymentMeansCode>58</cbc:PaymentMeansCode>
    <cac:PayeeFinancialAccount>
      <cbc:ID>DE02120300000000202051</cbc:ID>
    </cac:PayeeFinancialAccount>
  </cac:PaymentMeans>
  <cac:TaxTotal>
    <cbc:TaxAmount currencyID="EUR">0.00</cbc:TaxAmount>
    <cac:TaxSubtotal>
      <cbc:TaxableAmount currencyID="EUR">2408.40</cbc:TaxableAmount>
      <cbc:TaxAmount currencyID="EUR">0.00</cbc:TaxAmount>
      <cac:TaxCategory>
        <cbc:ID>O</cbc:ID>
        <cbc:TaxExemptionReasonCode>VATEX-EU-O</cbc:TaxExemptionReasonCode>
        <cac:TaxScheme>
          <cbc:ID>VAT</cbc:ID>
        </cac:TaxScheme>
      </cac:TaxCategory>
    </cac:TaxSubtotal>
    <cac:TaxSubtotal>
      <cbc:TaxableAmount currencyID="EUR">0.00</cbc:TaxableAmount>
      <cbc:TaxAmount currencyID="EUR">0.00</cbc:TaxAmount>
      <cac:TaxCategory>
        <cbc:ID>S</cbc:ID>
        <cbc:Percent>19.00</cbc:Percent>
        <cac:TaxScheme>
          <cbc:ID>VAT</cbc:ID>
        </cac:TaxScheme>
      </cac:TaxCategory>
    </cac:TaxSubtotal>
  </cac:TaxTotal>
  <cac:LegalMonetaryTotal>
    <cbc:LineExtensionAmount currencyID="EUR">2408.40</cbc:LineExtensionAmount>
    <cbc:TaxExclusiveAmount currencyID="EUR">2408.40</cbc:TaxExclusiveAmount>
    <cbc:TaxInclusiveAmount currencyID="EUR">2408.40</cbc:TaxInclusiveAmount>
    <cbc:PayableAmount currencyID="EUR">2408.40</cbc:PayableAmount>
  </cac:LegalMonetaryTotal>
  <cac:InvoiceLine>
    <cbc:ID>1</cbc:ID>
    <cbc:InvoicedQuantity unitCode="HUR">24.00</cbc:InvoicedQuantity>
    <cbc:LineExtensionAmount currencyID="EUR">2280.00</cbc:LineExtensionAmount>
    <cac:Item>
      <cbc:Name>Relaunch Website, Konzeption und Umsetzung</cbc:Name>
      <cac:ClassifiedTaxCategory>
        <cbc:ID>O</cbc:ID>
        <cac:TaxScheme>
          <cbc:ID>VAT</cbc:ID>
        </cac:TaxScheme>
      </cac:ClassifiedTaxCategory>
    </cac:Item>
    <cac:Price>
      <cbc:PriceAmount currencyID="EUR">95.00</cbc:PriceAmount>
    </cac:Price>
  </cac:InvoiceLine>
  <cac:InvoiceLine>
    <cbc:ID>2</cbc:ID>
    <cbc:InvoicedQuantity unitCode="C62">1.00</cbc:InvoicedQuantity>
    <cbc:LineExtensionAmount currencyID="EUR">128.40</cbc:LineExtensionAmount>
    <cac:Item>
      <cbc:Name>Lizenz Bildmaterial</cbc:Name>
      <cac:ClassifiedTaxCategory>
        <cbc:ID>O</cbc:ID>
        <cac:TaxScheme>
          <cbc:ID>VAT</cbc:ID>
        </cac:TaxScheme>
      </cac:ClassifiedTaxCategory>
    </cac:Item>
    <cac:Price>
      <cbc:PriceAmount currencyID="EUR">128.40</cbc:PriceAmount>
    </cac:Price>
  </cac:InvoiceLine>
</ubl:Invoice>

Sources